4th November 2025

The Scottish Police Authority (SPA) prepared a report for Police Scotland in September 2025 which was picked up by media today (4 November). In it they revealed there were 17 attempted murder cases involving 20 children between April and June this year, as compared to five cases for the same period in 2024.

Responding to this Dr Fern Gillon whose research and expertise is in youth violence and justice, said:

“It’s important to stress that overall trends in violence concerning young people do not appear to be rising, the vast majority of young people do not pose harm to others and young people should feel safe in their schools and communities. Recent isolated incidents involving young people are however tragic and concerning.

This reported rise in attempted murder statistics taken in conjunction with adult co-accused can be contextualised to current organised crime feuds where children are being criminally exploited. These statistics urge us to view particular violent episodes as exploitation and requires us to look behind the presenting behaviours. For example, as found in our recent research which highlighted concerns around violence between young people participants also raised concerns about violence ‘upon’ and ‘within’ – ‘upon’ being harms caused from above, be it social inequality, housing insecurity, school exclusion or justice involvement, and ‘within’ being anxiety, stress, mental health issues- with young people often self-medicating using illegal substances. These issues create conditions which criminal gangs can exploit and can be accounted for in some of the statistics.

If convicted of attempted murder these young people will receive considerable sentences, the issue is not ‘soft touch justice’. To attribute rising violence to ‘soft touch policies’ is to ignore children’s rights, the sustained cuts in public, third and voluntary sector funding and to ignore the lure of organised crime in the face of such austerity.

We heard from children and young people affected by violence about their concerns and the support they want to see: many couldn’t imagine a future where there would be opportunities. We need to create safe spaces in their local communities, providing a place for them to develop non-judgemental relationships with adults who can provide opportunities and support. But instead we found too many youth projects and community spaces shuttered, in some communities lying derelict. This isn’t good enough.

We must provide opportunities for those young people who are at risk of being affected by violence or criminally exploited, divert young people into viable alternatives and strengthen our condemnation of the conditions which result in young people being affected by violence or seeing organised crime is a solution to the lack of opportunity and hope. This requires commitment to a long-term approach to violence prevention, investment and funding and support to communities and grassroots organisations who are often best placed to intervene.”

Young People and Youth Justice